As Jim said, gelcoat has a shelf life. I've had it last longer than 90 days (in fact, just used some that I ordered last winter), but if it came with your boat (so is probably ten years old), then I'm not at all surprised it's not usable.
You can order it from a number of places pre-mixed to your color code (which should relieve you from the "artistic" color matching factor). Here is a list of color codes that Scot from Triton posted a while back. I used the code for the white gelcoat and the tailgate blue gelcoat and the white I can say is an excellent match for my 2002 22. I think the blue is too, but I've only used a tiny spot, so just don't have as much data on that yet.
I ordered from Gelcoat Products and had it shipped to me. I got cans of gelcoat with other, separate "ingredients," but they will also sell a gelcoat paste (which is slightly thickened and which they said has a longer shelf life) for smaller tasks. I believe Spectrum also commonly sells it. Here is the list of color codes I worked from:
1) Forest Green: Cook Composites # 953-GJ-081
2) Tailgate Blue: Cook Composites # 953-LJ-110
3) Cabarnet: Cook Composites # 953-MA-206
4) Roberts Gray: CCP # 963-AK-212
5) Black: CCP # 944-B-096
6) Cdory White Gelcoat: CCP # DX 963-WK-506
7) Cdory White Enamel: CCP # DX 948-WA-441
The CCP or Cook Composites number can be used like you would use a paint code in order to get the color from a number of different gelcoat vendors.
Sunbeam :hot
PS: I'm wondering if the thread title was a victim of Auto Correct
