New Hampshire Guy":15ur0yk9 said:
Dear Brats and Brat Admin,
Y-Landing Marine Services is introducing the C-Dory at an upcoming boat show in Providence RI. We would like to have a TV or computer set up so passers-by can view a sort of slide show of the C-Dory boats in action.
Unfortunately with the boats so new to us and the snow and ice up here we wouldn't be able to show very much with the pictures we've got.
Would it be possible to get permission to show some photos from your site?
Do we have to ask each owner?
Just let us know the hoops and we'll start-a jumpin!
All the best to the Brats and Happy New Year!
John
History, indeed. NO WHERE in the above post does it say you will be using the images as part of your advertising other than on a TV or computer slide show. Think it's no big deal? How would you feel if someone here "borrowed" one of your boats for the weekend? Hey, we wouldn't hurt it; we just want to use it for a while; we'll even pay for the gas! You would either call the Police or expect some sort of payment. You had a lot of folks offer their images for your original purpose... perhaps those same folks would have allowed usage for OTHER advertising HAD YOU ASKED.
I am a retired professional photographer. When I sold an image, there was an intended usage. If the client used the image again for another purpose, they paid again or usage was not allowed. Unless the work was done on a "for hire" basis, and rarely does a professional do that. You are dealing with a lot of good folks here who out of the goodness of their hearts and love for these boats offered their images for a slideshow. A big sigh and a reference to "history" doesn't change things and automatically turn a "slideshow" into web advertising or give you carte blanche to take images from this site to use for advertising.
You may think I'm the bad guy here, but after having thousands of dollars of images stolen from me, I got serious about image theft and did I all could to make that "what does it hurt?" type of thinking stop. You may be very nice folks, but what you did was wrong... even if that was not your intent. Dr. Bob is again oh-so-right: you could have nipped this in the bud, but your attitude of "Ahh, history" smacks of indifference.
I don't have a dog in this fight, but I know what's fair. Take the few seconds and ASK each person. Most would likely be pleased to help.
Respectfully,
Jim B
The images I post here are personal snapshots, intentionally low resolution... just for this reason. I sure have NO intention of turning this issue into a crusade here. I will now go back to being retired... y'all work this out amongst yourselves.