Hi Warren,
Timing is everything. If you want to stay in the Continental US and find warm (that's a relative term) winter boating, you have south Florida, south Texas, and San Diego. Of those three, I feel south Florida has the most interesting cruising opportunities. Any of those three can have great weather... or what you experienced. As it turned out this year, I think deep south Texas was by far the best. Checking the long range forecasts (certainly not always accurate), we decided to forgo Florida and had a wonderful winter in the Tropical Tip of Texas. It's a crap shoot.
Having said that, winter in any of the three above just has to be easier than winter in the frozen northland... given the same circumstances. Joan said it best: "If it's going to be crappy and cold, I'd rather be at our home in Texas. We can still go out in the boat any time we want, but if the wind is howling and the temps drop, it's a lot more comfortable in the house than the boat." After bailing out of Florida in November, I completely agree. Living on a small boat (even when it's not permanent, if you are out for more than a couple weeks, it's "living") takes a certain mind-set. Definitely not the same as a summer vacation.
3500 miles is a long haul. You have done RVing... you know there is a REAL difference between a modern RV and using the boat as a camper. We are enjoying being out in our 5th wheel right now - it is downright luxurious compared to Wild Blue... great insulation, lots of hot water, large holding tanks, 50 amp electrical service, satellite TV, a two-stage furnace and a fireplace, huge storage, room to walk around the bed... well, I could go on and on. The C-Dory is a place to sleep on land, but it certainly isn't an RV. There is no good way to handle waste water. You have to climb up and down each time you come and go. And let's face it - the campground neighbors give you funny looks. :wink: It is better suited to being on the water. We try to plan our boat hauling so we can put the boat in the water frequently along the way... not an easy thing to do when hauling to Florida in the winter. Certainly, a disadvantage.
The winter we spent in Florida, we put the boat in once and took it out when we were ready to head home; that eliminated the problems with ramps, campgrounds, etc. The downside is you have no vehicle for land travel while you're out on the boat. Public transportation can be your friend. Of course, being able to pull the boat out for repair/service sure makes the trailer nice. A big ol' trawler would be be comfy, but it's a REALLY LONG haul from WA, down through the Panama Canal (think Florida campgrounds are expensive???) and up around to the east coast. It would be important to get comfortable with some Spanish phrases like: where can we buy fuel, is there someplace who can repair my bent prop, etc, etc.
Our winter in Florida in 07 was also an "unusual" one according to the locals. We wore coats a lot. There were days at anchor when we couldn't get off the boat because of concerns about dragging in the howling wind. Hauling laundry in the dinghy. LOTS of walking. The breaks with warm weather and sunshine made it all easier. We tried to watch the weather and put ourselves in the best possible place considering what was coming. Like you, we were grateful that our Wallas was such a champ.
Traveling with a dog? Yeah, it's probably best if I don't go there, other than to say we have done that. Pat may make fun of our litterbox, but we never had to row to shore because of an impending bladder explosion. :shock: It is easier to travel without a furry family member, but we have been doing it for most of our lives.
We enjoyed reading about your travels... winced on occasion... saw yet another norther coming your way and hoped you were on the south side with some protection. Thanks for sharing it with us.
Best wishes,
Jim