Anna Leigh, Your paying the same to insure your $91,000 boat with Progressive as I am paying to insure 17 year old Adeline with Travelers, yet HER agreed value policy is only $25,000. Sooo, I contacted Progressive and got a quote of my own. Notably, boats(including motor(s), trailer, and equipment) 15 years old and older are limited to $20,000 total. With that in mind I was quoted $440/year. That's $20,000 in boat,motor(s), trailer, and all equipment for $440/year. At that rate insuring a $91,000 package would run $2002/year. When I asked the agent to explain the difference all she offered was your different zip code. In other words, I'm quoted at a rate 455% higher because I live in Vancouver instead of Guemes Island.