Porta Potti conversion

A

Alyssa Jean

Active member
Joined
Nov 2, 2003
Messages
2,376
Reaction score
0
C Dory Year
2005
C Dory Model
user_field_choice.c_dory_model_16_Angler
Vessel Name
Alyssa Jean
I am getting ready to pull the pump toilet in the boat and replace it with a good porta potti. Anyone have any suggestions on which porta potti might be the better choice? I am currently looking at the Thelford 365 at $199. Although I think I can get it for less.

I am going to take out the macerator, valve, hoses and tank. Just use the porta potti in the enclosed head and can move it to the cockpit if I want to actually stand in the shower.
 
Hello,

Check my photo folder "C-Nile" to view pictures of the Thetford Curve (its a sub folder located on the lower left corner of the page.) It is the same height and dimensions as our toilet at home, and is packed with features. In my opinion, it is the perfect toilet for your application. On our Marinaut, we intend to keep the Curve in the cockpit enclosure utilizing curtains for privacy.

Rich
 
David, Good move and you won't regret it at least after you have the pieces all pulled out. The storage available in the tank area is fantastic through that center hatch. I would recommend pulling out the hatch entirely while working on the tank because that hole gets more usefull the larger it is. I found a jigsaw the most useful for cutting the tank into pieces for removal but did use a cordless reciprocating saw as well. I pulled the macerator as well and used that outlet hose to add a backup bilge pump under the cockpit floor next to the primary.

We used the Dometic 976 marine model with compressed air flush and had good luck with that model. I would also opt for the curve if I were to do it today. I did replace the hose and had that connected to the potti for pumpout but simplicity without the hose/pumpout would be nice as well. If you connect it to a pumpout hose, it is a little work to disconnect if you ever need to manually dump it. We had a vent line running through the wall of the head and smell was never an issue but I am not sure how it would be with just the head alone in there. I would think a solar vent or cracked window would be enough anyway.

With the 5+ gallon model, You should get a week of boat living out of it before needing to empty.

Greg
 
We have that Thetford 365 on our 16 footer. We are very pleased with it. It's taller than the usual pottie which is a great feature for us. Since we don't have either a cutty or a head compartment we made a hassock-like cover for it with a cushion on top and it functions well as a passenger seat .
 
David,

I did that with the Thetford 365 two years ago. It sits higher and is a better fit in the head. Much simpler to deal with. Don't let it get full, it gets heavy to move.
 
If being legal is a concern - you may want to check the state laws where you boat. In some states and here in Ontario the law regarding what type of porta potty can be used on a boat is fairly strict. Just a thought.
 
Robert, Perhaps you might provide a short overview of the current rules pertaining to "porta-potties" at Ontario. I know you are located diametrically opposite of where I was planning to cruise which is from Ellison Bay, Door County, Wisconsin to the North Channel this summer. I have a "22 Cruiser" which has the standard porta-potty and a "five gallon" plastic bucket if needed! What sort of obstacles would I expect to encounter with this arrangement?
 
We often cross Lake Erie into Ontario and have never had anyone comment on it at all. Once I asked a very friendly customs guy about it and he said, "Law? What law?" and gave us a wink.

My impression, based on OUR experience, is that if you don't do something dumb, you will probably be okay.

Should I put a legal disclaimer in here?

Nick
"Valkyrie"
 
Okay, head is out, hose from head to tank is out, hose and macerator is out and I have drilled and sealed the three mounting holes. Now comes the fun part. DA TANK. I am putting this off a few days. In the meantime I have yet to make a decision on a porta potti.
 
I just went through this a couple of weeks ago, but elected to leave the tank in. That way if the boat is sold, the new owner (or me if that's what it took to make the sale) would have an easier time converting it back to the marine head. We ended up with a Thetford unit, because it was what we were used to in the travel trailer, (a 1954 Bellwood 14 footer)
 
Barry- no need for alarm, the "Porta Potty Police" aren't going to stop you at the Ontario border and check your luggable loo!! Legally , however boats must be fitted with a Type 111 MSD. That means it must have a holding tank with a deck mounted pump out fitting and a separate vent. Here is a link for you to check out re. Ontario marine laws. http://www.tc.gc.ca/eng/marinesafety/de ... nu-873.htm
I bought a new Stingray last year that came fitted with a porta potty which technically is not legal in Ontario. Its safe to say there are thousands of boats here that don't meet legal standards. Like Valkrie said, as long as your not dumping your loo overboard - I don't think anybody will bother you. I just raised this question to give pause for thought before anybody rips out a legal system to replace it with a porta potty. I did hear that you can get dual use units that have a pump out and a detachable tank that can be removed and emptied.
Enjoy the North Channel, its a great cruising ground.
Regards, Rob
 
Hi,

The following are pictures from my photo album of a Thetford 775 MSD in place. I can use it as a stand alone or as pump out. I performed the installation because of cruising in Canadian waters. Like most others who have already replied, I have never been boarded or checked in Canadian waters for the presence of a self contained head. Though I have the capabilities of using it as a pump out, I have never done so prefering to use it as a portable head.

[/img]http://www.c-brats.com/modules.php?set_albumName=album162&id=IMG_0141&op=modload&name=gallery&file=index&include=view_photo.php
modules.php


Best regards,
Rollie/C-Batical
 
I think these are Rolle's pictures
IMG_0141.sized.jpg
IMG_0140.sized.jpg
 
Hi Marty,

Thanks for the posting. You beat me to the punch. I was just going back to edit, when there the photos were.

Thanks again,
Rollie
 
Just finished removing the top of the poly tank. I now have a 25 gal dry storage box. I rinsed the tank about 4 times yesterday at the marina and attacked the thing this morning. It was surprisingly clean and no odor at all. I used a variable speed cutting tool that looks like a dentists drill with a 1 1/4 inch cuting disk. Worked great right up to the side corners.
 
If dryer storage is what you need good job so far. If storage for longer items plus more volume would be helpful, you could remove the whole tank. Ours had the elevated battery trays and the space beneath them is very useful and accessable with the tank out of the way.
 
I'd go with an Air Head or some other composting toilet, unless they are verboten in Canadia. You'd be surprised how infrequently you need to "mess" with it.
 
I got rid of my porta potty and replaced it with a 5 gal. bucket with a seat designed for 5 gal. buckets. I then use a plastic trash can liner and cat little in the bottom. Works great for weekend trips more comfortable than porta potty.

Don't know what Ontario would say about it.

Ron
 
Back
Top